
This from John Howson’s blog on 29th November 2018:
The final post in my series looking at the ITT Census for 2018, published last Thursday, considers the relative fortunes of schools and higher education in recruiting trainees on to teacher preparation courses. When Michael Gove was Secretary of State for Education, the direction of travel was clear: away from higher education as the provider of courses and towards a school-led and based system. How well has that direction of travel survived some three Secretaries of State later?
In the 2018 census the increase in secondary trainees has been concentrated in the higher education and SCITT sectors.
Secondary | 2017 Census | 2018 Census | Difference | % change | |
Higher Education | 6965 | 7965 | 1000 | 14% | |
SCITT | 1955 | 2435 | 480 | 25% | |
School Direct Fee | 3780 | 4170 | 390 | 10% | |
School Direct Salaried | 1080 | 905 | -175 | -16% | |
Teach First | 915 | 760 | -155 | -17% | |
PG apprenticeship | na | 20 | |||
Total | 14695 | 16255 | 1560 | 11% |
Source DfE Data Table 1a and Table 9 ITT census 2018
SCITTS continue to flourish, with an increase of a quarter in trainee numbers, whereas the other school-centred courses have not shared in the overall increase in trainee numbers to the same extent, with the most expensive salaried routes experiencing declines in trainee numbers. In the secondary sector, the postgraduate teaching apprenticeship route has have only a minimal impact this year.
In the primary sector, where recruitment controls were more important, there has been far less change between this year and last year.
Primary | 2017 Census | 2018 Census | Difference | |
Higher Education | 5660 | 5605 | -55 | |
SCITT | 1390 | 1565 | 175 | |
School Direct Fee | 3350 | 3365 | 15 | |
School Direct Salaried | 1690 | 1830 | 140 | |
Teach First | 410 | 395 | -15 | |
PG apprenticeship | na | 70 | ||
Total | 12500 | 12830 | 330 |
Source DfE Data Table 1a and Table 9 ITT census 2018
In the primary sector, higher education seems to be still less favoured than the school-based routes; with both SCITTS and the School Direct Salaried routes recording more trainees than last year. The postgraduate teaching apprenticeship route has more primary participants than secondary, but its first year has not made a significant contribution to the supply of new teachers.
Overall across both sectors, SCITTs are under-represented in the London area. This may partly be because London schools have the most School Direct Salaried and Teach First new entrants, accounting for more than one third of those on both routes. By contrast, the South West that participates in both programmes has relatively few numbers on either of these routes into teaching and nearly 60% of new entrants in the region are on higher education programmes.
Teach First seemed especially good at recruiting me to primary courses, achieving a three per cent higher outcome than other routes this year, but, by contrast, especially poor at recruiting me to secondary courses, achieving only a 31% outcome, compared with the 40% of trainees figure for high education courses.
Where higher education excels is in recruiting new graduates. Of course, the School Direct Salaried route is not open to new young graduates, but compared with the routes that take all-comers, higher education recruits the higher percentage of those under 25, accounting for 50% of the higher education intake this year: albeit down from 51% last year, a warning sign for the future. SCITTS only recruited 45% of their intake for the under 25s, perhaps signifying the importance of their more local recruitment focus, in many areas with a high percentage of career changers.
With the number of eighteen year olds dropping for the next few years, while the demand for new secondary teachers will be increasing, as the school population increases, nurturing the young new graduate market may well be important: that might mean a re-assessment of fees and other support for all trainees.
However, should the Bank of England’s predictions for 2019 and the years following any departure from the EU prove correct in terms of the economy, it is possible that teaching might once again seem like an attractive career in an unstable world: after all, there will always be children to educate.